Busting 5 Common Myths About Cats and Their Eating Habits

Cats have a reputation for being finicky creatures, especially when it comes to food.

But how much of what we believe about feline eating habits is true?

Let’s dive into the science and debunk five common myths about cats and their diets, starting with the classic “cats are fussy eaters.”

Myth 1: Cats Are Naturally Fussy Eaters

The Truth: Cats aren’t inherently picky; their eating habits are driven by their acute sense of smell and taste. A 2018 study in the Journal of Feline Medicine and Surgery highlights that cats rely heavily on olfactory cues to assess food.

Warming wet food to around body temperature (about 38°C/100°F) releases volatile compounds, enhancing the aroma and making the food more appealing.

This explains why a slightly warmed meal often entices even the most “fussy” cat.

Cats may also avoid food due to stress, illness, or poor-quality diets, not because they’re naturally choosy.

By offering palatable, high-quality food and warming it slightly, you can often turn a hesitant eater into an enthusiastic one.

Myth 2: Cats Can Thrive on a Vegetarian Diet

The Truth: Cats are obligate carnivores, meaning they require nutrients like taurine, arachidonic acid, and vitamin A found primarily in animal tissues.

A 2020 review in Animals emphasizes that plant-based diets lack these essential nutrients, and deficiencies can lead to serious health issues like heart disease or blindness.

While supplements can help, they’re not a reliable substitute for meat-based diets. Feeding your cat a balanced, meat-rich diet is non-negotiable for their health.

Myth 3: Cats Don’t Need Fresh Water if They Eat Wet Food

The Truth: While wet food provides significant moisture (about 70-80% water content), it’s not a complete substitute for fresh water.

A 2019 study in Veterinary Sciences notes that cats have a low thirst drive due to their desert-dwelling ancestors, making them prone to dehydration if water intake is inadequate.

Fresh, clean water encourages drinking and supports urinary and kidney health, especially for cats on mixed or dry food diets. Always keep a water bowl accessible.

Myth 4: Milk Is a Healthy Treat for Cats

The Truth: Many cats are lactose intolerant after weaning, as their bodies produce less lactase, the enzyme needed to digest lactose.

A 2021 article in Journal of Veterinary Internal Medicine explains that giving milk to adult cats can cause digestive upset, including diarrhea. Instead, opt for cat-safe treats or lactose-free milk formulated for felines to avoid tummy troubles.

Myth 5: Cats Can Eat the Same Food Every Day Without Issue

The Truth: While cats can be creatures of habit, a monotonous diet may not meet all their nutritional needs over time and can lead to food boredom or sensitivities.

A 2022 study in Frontiers in Veterinary Science suggests that dietary variety can support gut health and reduce the risk of food intolerances.

Rotating protein sources (e.g., chicken, fish, turkey) and incorporating high-quality supplements can keep your cat’s diet balanced and engaging.

Takeaway

Cats aren’t as fussy as we think—they’re just wired differently!

By understanding their biology and busting these myths, you can make mealtime enjoyable and nutritious.

Try warming wet food to enhance its appeal, ensure fresh water is always available, and choose high-quality, meat-based diets with occasional variety.

Your cat will thank you with purrs and a healthy appetite.